Theatres often rely on volunteers, limited time, and small marketing budgets to promote productions, recruit volunteers, and announce auditions. While platforms like Facebook and Instagram make it easy to reach local audiences, many theatre posts unintentionally limit their effectiveness through common marketing mistakes.

The good news? Most of these issues can be fixed with a few simple adjustments. Learn how to spot common theatre social media mistakes, prevent them, and see examples based on real social media posts.

---

Cast Lists That Can’t Be Updated and De-Prioritize Others

Cast announcements are some of the most anticipated posts in a theatre’s social media calendar. Actors, friends, and family members are excited to share the news, often resulting in high engagement.

The example above includes the full cast list inside the graphic. While visually appealing, long lists become difficult to read on mobile devices and aren’t easily accessible for screen readers or alt text. They also create unnecessary work if a name is misspelled, someone is accidentally omitted, or the cast changes after the graphic has been published.

The design also gives greater visual emphasis to principal roles while making ensemble names much smaller. Although unintentional, this can create the perception that ensemble members are less important to the production.

Instead, let the graphic announce the cast, and use the caption for the full cast list in a clean, easy-to-read format. For larger productions, consider introducing cast members over multiple posts to extend engagement throughout rehearsals.

Promotional Posts that Read Like Press Releases

Many theatre posts try to accomplish too much at once.

The example post shown above demonstrates this challenge well. In a single post, it attempts to:

• Describe the story
• Encourage audiences to attend
• List performance dates
• Explain how to purchase tickets
• Use decorative formatting and multiple exclamation points
• Credit the graphic designer
• Include numerous hashtags
• Display a production poster with difficult-to-read text
• Add a QR code that can’t realistically be scanned while viewing the post on a mobile device

While each element has good intentions, together they create a wall of text that many users will scroll past. Promotional posts work best when they have one clear objective.

Designer credits are another consideration. While recognizing your production team is important, regularly crediting individual designers or staff members in promotional captions can unintentionally create expectations for future productions. If one graphic designer is credited in every post, the next designer may expect the same treatment. The same can happen with stage managers, directors, or other production staff. (Photographers and videographers may be exceptions if credit is required by contract.)

Instead, recognize your team through dedicated designer spotlights, volunteer appreciation posts, or opening- and closing-night acknowledgments. This keeps promotional content focused on your audience while ensuring consistent recognition.

Think of your social media graphics and captions like a billboard on the highway: your audience has only 3 seconds to see, read, and resonate with the post. Before you publish, ask yourself:

• Am I trying to include too much information in a single post?
• Does this post have one clear purpose?
• Is the message easy to read and understand?
• Can someone understand the post without reading the caption?

Audition Details Not Included

Audition announcements often prioritize aesthetics over useful information.

The example above clearly identifies the production, but actors still need to know when auditions take place, where they’re held, and how to sign up. If all of that information appears only in the caption, the graphic becomes less useful when it’s shared.

A themed image can still capture attention, but include the essential audition details either on the graphic or in an easy-to-scan caption. For more extensive information, link to your website or create a Facebook event with complete audition details.

---

Small Improvements Can Make a Big Difference

Great theatre marketing doesn’t require a large budget or professional design team. By focusing on clarity, consistency, and your audience’s experience, small changes can make your social media posts easier to read, easier to share, and more effective.

Need help developing your theatre’s marketing strategy? Beyond Theatre Collective offers marketing consulting services to help community, educational, and nonprofit theatres create marketing that connects with audiences and sells more tickets.